I'm not very advantageous when it comes to food, so I limited myself to their prix fixe menu so I basically had American fare but it was fabulous!
The waiter was excellent; very attentive without being obnoxious. He knew when we needed more water, another drink, more bread and/or butter without ever being asked. He even discreetly brought me another fork just before my dinner came out.
The restaurant actually is closed because the building was sold, but La Cigale will re-open at another location in October.....look out for it it is worth it!