It is worth the drive to Menemsha to experience the best fried clams on the island! Everything else is good too, but he clams are what I make the trip for. Expect to wait, everything is cooked to order. Sit at one of the picnic tables, or take the short walk do to the beach and enjoy the sunset.
Pros: Cooked to order fried seafood, homemade sides, something for everyone!
Cons: can be long wait, limited parking