Found this place driving by it on a tour bus and noticed the host outside talking to some folks. He looked very happy. So, we tried it on a whim and was pleasantly surprised. We had Caesar salad, garlic bread, Chicken Parmesan, Pasta Primavera, Pizza, and a dish I forgot the name of with marinara sauce with green olives and anchovies over pasta. It was all great. The host met us at the door, visited with us and walked us to our table. He also checked on us during the meal. Entrees in the $9-16 range, very reasonable considering it is so close to Rockefeller Plaza. Will definitely go back the next time I'm in NY.
Pros: Great food, very nice staff, reasonably priced
Cons: Hard to find