This gem of a consignment shop feels like shopping in a boutique. Located in the village of Fairport, this shop is open for a few months per season. They close for about a month between seasons, before which they run a fabulous sale for two weeks where the prices continuously go down. Last fall I picked up a pair of Yves Saint Laurent silver strappy sandals for $1 on the last day!
The store owner loves what she is doing. She will help you find things and chat with you easily. The store is small, but well organized, with clothing sorted by size and also by type (pants, tops, dresses, shoes, purses).
It is a well-off area so the clothes are name-brand, many never used and with the tags still on.