I live next door to this place. I bought one, by the time I got home the grease soaked through the bag. Greasy Pizza with canned pizza sauce, locals don't go, and there is never a wait, with good reason. Construction workers who bought pizza there sat on our stoop and would drain the grease off, 3 weeks later, grease stains are still there. In NYC there is always something better around the corner, Due Amici, 3rd Ave and 13th St., better yet, Viva Herbal Pizza, 179 Second Ave between 11&12th St., better Pizza, healthier choices. If you're out at 2 am drunk out of your mind then Anna Maria might taste good. I forgot to mention the incredibly tacky ""decor"" too many mirrors and enough flourescent lighting to blind you, wear sunglasses, that way no one will recognize you if you happen to stumble in this dump.
Cons: greasy, canned sauce, tacky decor