JavaScript is not enabled.
Amelia's - Milwaukee, WI - Reviews page 1 - Judysbook

Amelia's

Claim
marker
724 E Layton Ave (at Corner Of Pine And Layton Ave)
Milwaukee, WI 53207
marker
(414) 483-0345
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Main categories:

Restaurants , Reception Centers

Related categories:

Food & Dining

Photos

Amelia's - Milwaukee, WI
Amelia's - Milwaukee, WI
Amelia's - Milwaukee, WI
Amelia's - Milwaukee, WI
Amelia's - Milwaukee, WI
Amelia's - Milwaukee, WI
Amelia's - Milwaukee, WI
Amelia's - Milwaukee, WI
Amelia's - Milwaukee, WI
Amelia's - Milwaukee, WI
Amelia's - Milwaukee, WI

Reviews

( 2 )
( 2 )
( 2 )
( 0 )
( 6 )

Best

We had arrived in Milwaukee and found this establishment listed in a restaurant brochure from the lobby. The photograph in the brochure was totally inaccurate as it showed a sto...

Worst

The food was undercooked and bland . The server was arrogant and rude . The female in charge ( Brenda) didn't care and was not concerned about her ...

Terrible 12/23/2014

4495 Provided by Partner
The food was undercooked and bland . The server was arrogant and rude . The female in charge ( Brenda) didn't care and was not concerned about her ... more

Amelia's July 2013 7/22/2013

Inconsistent service and food, is my opinion of how to describe Amelia's. If they "know" you, food and... more

Amelia's July 2013 7/22/2013

Madryn Provided by Partner
Inconsistent service and food, is my opinion of how to describe Amelia's. If they "know" you, food and service is great to excellent. If not, well ... more


Save your Money!!! 2/15/2011

Do not spend money here , Do not even think about going here . The food is awful. The Staff are drunk , on drugs and unpleasent unhappy people that dont want to be there, so dont waste your money more

Never disappointed! 12/14/2010

My husband and I have been to Amelia's many times, either for the all you can eat crab or for the fish fry. The fish fry is excellent, especially the lb of lake perch. It's so tender and moist! The crab is delicious! You know it's good when you can crack the leg and pull out all of the meat and it's so sweet that you don't need to use the melted butter! The staff was always super nice and our waitress was right there with another bucket of crab before we are done with the current bucket. Same goes for the all you can eat Cod fish fry, that waitress was also very attentive. more

Unsatisfactory 10/31/2010

The place has a nice theme to it but the staff is rude acts very unprofessional at the bar. From our waitress to the bartenders you could tell they did not want to be there and if it wasnt for drinking shots and and talking to one another , they wouldnt be there. If you needed something forget it, the staff acts like they are doing you a favor. Amelias staff and service is Unsatisfactory.... more

Yeah right ! 7/18/2010

Do not complain about anything here at Amelia's or you will be ignored. This place is drama . It doesnt matter how much money you spend or how well you tip , The employees dont care. The owner Brenda does not care about her customers. Her attitude is eat your food drink your drink , shut your mouth and be grateful we served you, and pay for it and leave a big tip Sucker! How does this place last You dont believe me look at the other reviews and the other web sites....... Pros: The Staff Cons: No Cons more

Pleasantly Surprised! 7/11/2010

We had arrived in Milwaukee and found this establishment listed in a restaurant brochure from the lobby. The photograph in the brochure was totally inaccurate as it showed a stone fire place and a brightly lit dining room. When we found Amelia's I was shocked that it was really just a "hole in the wall" if you will. The decor however drew me in, and the place mat which included the flight plan of Amelia Earhart kept me intrigued until our very friendly waitress came to our table. The food was quickly served and delicious. I had the roast beef with fries and cole slaw. The portions were heaping, and I was unable to eat the whole serving despite the deliciousness of it. Our waitress was wonderful, she took our picture under the "Welcome to Amelia's" sign when we told her we were from Pittsburgh. Bottom line DO NOT judge a book by its cover! Pros: Great Ambiance, Great Food, Great Wait Staff! Cons: Loud... more

FOOD IS ABSOLUTELY TERRIBLE 5/2/2009

Had a fish fry once before and it was overcooked and dry. I let it go thinking that it was a busy night and all cooks make mistakes.\r \r Had another fish fry tonight and again....TERRIBLE! Absolutely the WORST fish I have ever had. Like eating scales and cardboard.\r \r Also had taken clients there for lunch several times because of the convenience to the airport. I must say that even the lunches were bad. The waitresses are rude and food takes forever.\r \r Tonight was the last straw. No more Amelia's for me. more

bad service/bad food 10/21/2007

The waitress was rude to my elderly father. Told him to look in the menu for specials. Her fingers and shirt were filthy. Our drinks were weak and the food was screwed up(we said no onions,got onions) (We asked for medium well, we got bloody bun) Our waitress offeren no help. When I asked for a manager I was told there was not one there to call the next day. She put gratuity on our bill for 4 adults and 1 child. When I told her I would not pay she said it was illegal and she would call the cops. Nice try. more

Good Food 9/16/2007

Surprisingly good food from this bar. They have daily specials like all you can eat crab legs or ribs. They do have the typical pub food but also have great seafood. more

Great Outdoor Dining 6/23/2006

Great Food. Sweet waitresses. Get to watch airplanes take off and land. Comfortable, and relaxed. Fun place to go for just a drink and appetizer. Pros: Food and Service Cons: Traffic more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for Amelia's




CYBERWEEK:
50% OFF all yearly plans
Use CYBERWEEK at checkout. Expires 12/4/2016

Owner Message

  • Restaurants

Additional information

  • Hours:

    mon 11:00 am-01:00 am ; tue 11:00 am-01:00 am ; wed 11:00 am-01:00 am ; thu 11:00 am-01:00 am ; fri 11:00 am-01:00 am ; sat 11:00 am-01:00 am ; sun 11:00 am-01:00 am
  • Payments:

    Master Card, Visa
  • Neighborhoods:

    Town of Lake

Best Deals and Recommendations