JavaScript is not enabled.
Agostino's Ristorante - Cleveland, OH - Reviews page 1 - Judysbook

Agostino's Ristorante

Claim
marker
4218 Ridge Rd
Cleveland, OH 44144
marker
(216) 741-6522
Incorrect info? Correct your listing

Reviews

( 3 )
( 2 )
( 1 )
( 1 )
( 2 )

Best

This is now under NEW ownership and the food is outstanding! The Jam Night on Tuesday's is awesome!

Worst

My family of 5 arrived at around 5pm and there was only 1 person eating in there. We were sat by a gentleman in an apron (cook?) and we said we had a child with us and still gave ...

bad, bad 2/3/2012

My family of 5 arrived at around 5pm and there was only 1 person eating in there. We were sat by a gentleman in an apron (cook?) and we said we had a child with us and still gave us an adult menu for him said he can make anything on the menu for a child. He disappeared for awhile came back with bread and oil took our drink order came back 10min later said the blender was broken. He proceeded to take our order and disappeared again. Then a younger gentleman came out asked for our drink order and asked if we ordered already. Came back out 10mins later with water and more bread. We did get a kids menu too! We got our salads that came with the meal, not enough dressing for the salad. We finally got our drinks. We had also ordered mozzerella wedges and they were out and Chocolate milk for the little one and they had no milk either. We had 2 chicken marsallas and 2 veal parmagina and the ""cook"" guy that took our order messed it up. they gave us veal marsalla and chicken parm. We sent them back and the chicken came out 5 mins later and then the veal came out 5mins after that. My parents veal was well under cooked, werent able to cut it and my mom was able to taste the blood. We let the server know and we said that he was already taking care of the veal cause it took so long. We finally got out of there 1.5hrs later! Only 2 table in there the whole time. The waiter was at least nice enough to take care of the Veal portion of the bill but still, something didnt seem right. We were gonna use out whole $100 gc but only used $50 now we have to go back again to a place less desirable then Olive Garden. We wouldve gotten better food AND service there for the same price of $50. For a place with so many bad reviews, im surprised this place is still open! Im thinking it a front for the mafia, common, not being busy bad service no one there and the food getting messed up? id expect this from a restaurant grossing 300 guests an hr not 8 guests an hour. more

Bad Service, Bad Food 9/25/2010

My husband & I tried Agostino's for the first time last night. It will be our last. We waited to be seated, waited to get drinks, waited for our order to be taken, waited & waited for our food. At one point there 5 tables with customers, 2 waitresses, 1 bus boy & a couple that appeared to be the owners. With 5 customers & 5 employees you would expect great service! We could barely get anyone's attention to place our order. Our waitress kept disappearing in the back for 10-15 minutes at a time. All would have been forgiven if he food had been okay. It was not. The bacon wrapped scallops were cold. My seafood pizza which was suppose to have shrimp, scallops, & calamari had 1 shrimp, 2 scallops & seriously overcooked calamari. Lobster ravioli was okay. When we complained, our waitress apologized & said they were short handed. more

Agostino's Ristorante 8/16/2010

This is now under NEW ownership and the food is outstanding! The Jam Night on Tuesday's is awesome! more

LIKE WE WERENT EVEN THERE!!! 8/11/2010

So me and 4 others from work heard that this was a great place for lunch. we walk in at 11:40 and stand at the front counter for a couple of minutes. we noticed a female worker sitting at a table talking about what she was going to wear this weekend with her friends. After a few minutes of waiting and asking loudly if they were open, we left . She didnt even look back at us once. its a shame that i will never get to taste thier food because five of us decided never to go back.... more

Agostino's is back! 8/1/2010

Agostino's is back on Ridge Road in Brooklyn. On a recent visit my husband and I had a very pleasant experience. The atmosphere is quiet and subdued. Our food was delicious. Portions were large. My husband had the Chicken Parmesan which comes with a fresh house salad and a side of pasta. I had the mussles, which were delectable and tender. The best I've ever had. Pros: Great Italian Fare more

Not going back anytime soon 11/11/2008

I just had a very annoying experience at Agostino's. First I called in a take-out order and was put on hold TWICE, the first time for a very long time. (as far as being on hold goes) When I got there of course there was no parking in front, around back in the alley, or on the side street. So....I have to park across the street in the very UNLIT (and this at night) parking lot and walk across 4 lanes of traffic to get to the place. The lady on the phone had told me to come to the take-out area, which I discovered was in the back. Now I have to walk around the building in the dark, passing through cars randomly parked out back. Once inside I rang the bell and waited...............an employee walked by and yelled to someone that they needed to come back there. More time passed.................I rang the bell again and waited........finally a man who looked like a manager type came over to help me. So finally...I pay for my food and leave. When I got home, after eagerly anticipating my meal, I found out that for all my troubles they didn't even give me the pasta that comes with it. Soooo....in conclusion, the parking stinks and the service wasn't so hot either. Now, to be fair, I had eaten there before in the dining room. Same parking issue......and the service was slow, despite the diningroom being almost empty. I WILL say that the reason I went back the second time was because I really love their eggplant parmesan. But alas...I will have to get it elsewhere now. Cons: PARKING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! more

Great all-around 8/21/2002

Great food, couple with fast, friendly service makes this a wonderful restaurant to visit. The portions are generous (be prepared to ask for a doggie bag), and you'll be pleasantly surprised when you pick up the check. Cons: limited parking more

A Bit of Italy close to home! 8/8/2002

From the time your greeted at the door, until the time you pay the bill you'll have a wonderful dining experiance. The staff who by the way are real Itallian, not imitation, make you feel at home and important. The menu selections are varied and can temp anyone. The wine list is good and not high priced. As for desert all I can say is MAMA MIA. A definite don't miss! Pros: service, menu, quality more

This is the place! 7/23/2002

Absolutely the best food I ever had. Pleasant atmosphere and friendly staff. Parking is limited and you may have to park on a side street if you don't want to valet park. Surprisingly, the prices are quite reasonable. Pros: great food, efficient staff, reasonable price Cons: poor parking more
< Previous 1 Next >

Menu for Agostino's Ristorante




HOLIDAY DISCOUNT :
15% OFF all yearly plans
Use YEAR15 at checkout. Expires 12/31/2016

Additional information

  • Hours:

    Tues-Thurs 11AM to 10PM Fri 11AM to 11PM Sat 4PM to 11PM Sun Noon to 8PM Closed Mondays
  • Neighborhoods:

    Brooklyn, Old Brooklyn

Best Deals and Recommendations